Rotten Apples: Dead or Alive?
Following on from the article in last month's newsletter, we take a look at the chemical differences between fresh apples and those that have been left to rot and dehydrate. A fresh Fuji and Royal Gala apple were analysed using micro-XRF technology to investigate the chemical distributions in their structure. A month later the same apples were re-analysed to provide a comparison in the chemical distributions between the fresh and rotted fruit (Fig. 1).
Figure 1: Cross sections of the Fuji apple that were scanned when fresh (a) and after rotting for a month (b).
Apples are widely regarded as the most popular fruit available worldwide. They are high in fibre, antioxidants, vitamins (such as vitamin C) and minerals (potassium and calcium) and have been enjoyed by all since they were first cultivated (1). Originating from Central Asia and being first cultivated as early as 4000 years ago, apples have expanded to over 7500 different varieties worldwide (2).
While containing similar chemistry, each variety can be different in structure and mineral/elemental distribution. Additionally, within the fruit itself the chemistry can varying in both a longitudinal and lateral sense. Key regions such as the pith where seeds and carpellary bundles lie and hypanthium where much of the flesh is situated may concentrate certain elements based on position to the stem (see Fig. 2 and 3).
Figure 2. Diagram showing the longitudinal cross section of the apple from a flower evolving into a fruit. Drawing by M. Goffinet. (Taken from Lakso, A., Goffinet, M. 2013)
Figure 3. Diagram of lateral section of the apple showing gross morphology of apple fruit. ft, floral tube; s, sepal bundles; p, petal bundles; cl, outer limit of carpel or core line; dc, dorsal carpellary bundle; cb, carpellary bundles connecting dorsal with ventral carpellary bundles (Based on MacDaniels, 1940). (Taken from Herremans, E. et. Al 2015)
To identify chemical variations within the apples, the M4 Tornado micro-XRF was utilised to produce detailed element maps under atmospheric conditions. To observe the internal cross-sectional chemistry, two different apple varieties (Royal Gala and Fuji) were cut both on the and lateral planes for analysis. These two apple varieties were analysed when fresh, and again after being left to rot and dehydrate for a month (Fig. 1).
The dehydration of the apples caused the internal flesh to condense with the outer skin curling in on itself. The interior seed cavities became more pronounced and the reduction in the flesh enables the internal carpellary bundle of the core to be easily observed. Interestingly, the dehydration of the apples did not have much of an effect on the chemical variation between the fresh and rotted fruit.
The apples appeared to retained the same elemental distribution patterns within their structures, despite the beginnings of the decomposition. The elements are more concentrated within some of the structural zones such as the skin, carpel bundles and seed cavities due to the dehydration of the apples over the month. The vascular system that could be observed in the flesh of the fresh fruit is no longer defined after dehydration of the fruit.
For both the Fuji and Royal Gala apples, the dominant elements observed were potassium (K), calcium (Ca) and iron (Fe). These elements highlight the key structural regions of the apples, as well as nutrient pathways leading from the core to the outer skin (Fig. 4 and 5). Other minor elements identified were zinc (Zn), copper (Cu) and titanium (Ti), these were uniformly distributed throughout both varieties of apples, including within the seeds.
Figure 4: Cross sectional chemistry of the major elements between the fresh and rotten Fuji apple.
Figure 5: Cross sectional chemistry of the major elements between the fresh and rotten Royal Gala apple
Knowing the distribution of the critical elements such as Ca, Fe and K is crucial for fruit growers as knowledge about the internal chemical structure and element uptake can indicate the health of the crop, and in some cases flavour. Studies on Ca uptake by apple varieties such as Honeycrisp apples have shown lower uptake of Ca can lead to more bitter flavour (5). Additionally, knowing the elemental distribution as the apple decomposes may be key to understanding the shelf life of the fruit.